🇮🇩 ID | 🇬🇧 EN
🇮🇩 Read in Indonesian
Misconceptions

The Danger of Following Finfluencers

Finfluencers often sell dreams, not education. Learn why you should be skeptical of investment advice on social media.

•

Note: This article discusses Indonesian financial products and regulations. The underlying investment principles apply globally.

The Danger of Following Finfluencers

Open TikTok or Instagram, and you’ll be flooded with content like:

  • “How to make IDR 10 million per month from stocks!”
  • “The secret to 100% stock gains in a month!”
  • “My portfolio is up 200% — here’s how!”

They’re called finfluencers — financial influencers. The problem is, most of their advice is dangerous to your finances.

What Is a Finfluencer?

A finfluencer is a social media content creator who discusses investing, trading, or personal finance. They are NOT licensed financial advisors (most of them). They are content creators who happen to (or deliberately) choose finance topics because these topics generate massive attention.

Their business model:

  1. Free content → attract followers
  2. Paid courses → monetization (IDR 500,000 - IDR 5,000,000 per course)
  3. Affiliate links → commissions from investment platforms
  4. Paid promotions → paid by companies to promote products
  5. Pump and dump → in worst cases, promoting stocks they own to drive up the price

Their incentive is NOT to make you wealthy. Their incentive is to get engagement and sell courses.

Real Cases in Indonesia

Jouska (2020)

PT Jouska Finansial Indonesia operated as a financial advisor and influencer on social media. They:1

  • Managed client funds without authorization from OJK (Indonesia’s Financial Services Authority)
  • Promised high returns
  • Directed client funds to certain stocks benefiting internal parties
  • Were suspended by OJK’s Investment Alert Task Force (Satgas Waspada Investasi) in 2020
  • Clients lost billions of rupiah

Penny Stock Pumps on Telegram/Discord

Stock groups on Telegram and Discord often operate with this pattern:

  1. The “whale” buys a penny stock in large quantities
  2. Spreads “recommendations” to thousands of followers
  3. Followers buy → price rises
  4. Whale sells at high price
  5. Price crashes → followers lose money

This is classic pump and dump, and it’s illegal — but very hard to prove and rarely prosecuted.

Crypto Influencers

During the 2021 crypto bull market, many Indonesian influencers promoted:

  • Tokens they received for free from developers (undisclosed paid promotion)
  • DeFi projects that later rug-pulled
  • NFTs that are now worth nearly zero

How many of them posted updates after these projects collapsed? Almost none.

5 Finfluencer Red Flags

Be wary if you see these patterns:

1. Promising specific returns

“30% annual return guaranteed” or “Passive income of IDR 5 million per month from IDR 50 million in stocks.”

Reality: No investment can guarantee returns. The JCI (Jakarta Composite Index) averages ~10-12% per year over the long term2 — and even that isn’t consistent every year.

2. Only showing profits, never losses

Portfolio screenshots always green. Never discussing losing positions or drawdown periods.

Reality: All investors — including Warren Buffett — have experienced and will experience losses. If someone always profits, they’re lying or cherry-picking.

3. Selling urgency

“Stock X will skyrocket next week!” “Buy now before it’s too late!”

Reality: If someone truly knew which stock would rise, they would quietly buy it themselves — not tell millions of people on Instagram.

4. Luxury lifestyle as “proof”

Showing off cars, watches, luxury hotels as proof of investment success.

Reality: Their wealth (if real) usually comes from selling courses and products, not from investing. Some even rent properties and luxury items just for content.

5. Selling “secret” classes

“I’ll share my secret strategy in my exclusive class — only IDR 2,000,000.”

Reality: There are no secret strategies in investing. Proven investment principles (diversification, low costs, long-term) are already available for free everywhere. Including on this site.

Why Finfluencer Advice Is Often Wrong

They have no qualifications

In Indonesia, to become an official investment advisor, you need:

  • A license from OJK (Indonesia’s Financial Services Authority)
  • WMI (Investment Manager Representative) or WPPE (Securities Broker Representative) certification
  • Strict oversight and reporting obligations

Finfluencers? They only need a phone and social media account. There’s no quality filter.

Their incentives conflict with yours

  • You need boring but correct advice: “Buy index funds every month”
  • They need engaging content: “10 stocks that will 100x this year!”

Correct advice and viral advice are almost never the same.

They’re not responsible for your losses

Licensed financial advisors have legal obligations (fiduciary duty). If their advice causes losses due to negligence, they can be sued.

Finfluencers? They write a small “not financial advice” disclaimer and are free from any responsibility.

What Should You Do?

1. Be skeptical of all investment advice on social media

Including from accounts with millions of followers. Popularity is not an indicator of truth. Always verify if investment products are registered with OJK before investing.

2. Seek evidence-based sources

Read academic research, data from OJK (Financial Services Authority) and BEI (Indonesia Stock Exchange), classic investment books. Some recommendations:

  • “A Random Walk Down Wall Street” by Burton Malkiel
  • “The Little Book of Common Sense Investing” by John Bogle
  • SPIVA data from S&P Dow Jones Indices (proof that active fund managers underperform the index)

3. Ask: “How does this person make money?”

If they sell courses, affiliate links, or product promotions — their advice is biased. That doesn’t mean it’s always wrong, but you should know their motivation.

4. Follow principles, not predictions

Proven principles:3

These will never become viral content, but this is what actually works.

Summary

Finfluencer SaysReality
”30% annual return”JCI averages ~10-12%, no guarantees
”I always profit”All investors experience losses
”Buy stock X now!”No one can predict short-term stock prices
”Join my secret class”Correct investment principles are available for free
”Look at my lifestyle”Usually from selling courses, not from investing

Boring investing doesn’t make for viral content. But boring investing is what actually works.

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only, not investment advice.

Footnotes

  1. Jouska’s business activities were suspended by OJK’s Investment Alert Task Force for operating without a license. Sources: Bisnis.com (July 22, 2020), Bareksa (July 22, 2020) ↩

  2. Historical JCI returns vary by period. Historical data available at Indonesia Stock Exchange. Past returns do not guarantee future returns. ↩

  3. For a complete guide to starting safe passive investing, read Summary: Start Here. ↩

Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Always do your own research and consult with a licensed financial advisor before making investment decisions.

In this category: